Quality problems may occur at any stage from the approval of the drawings to the purchase of materials, and from the processing of components to the completion of the finish, electrical assembly, packaging and transportation. Quality control should begin with the drawing and sample approval and then continue with incoming inspection, processing, assembly and testing, and finally in the shipment.

This article outlines the actual production sequence and provides a description of the inspection methods for pre-production standards, IQC, IPQC, finish, completed fixture assembly, electrical testing, PSI and common defects.

1. How Do You Establish Quality Standards for Decorative Lighting Before Mass Production?

Prior to mass production, determine product specifications, approved samples and methods of acceptance so that IQC, production inspection and PSI are based on the same criteria.

1) Confirm the Final Drawing, Specification, and BOM

Before mass production, confirm at least the Final Drawing, BOM, Material Specification, Electrical Specification, and Packaging Requirement, and identify the Revision Number. For example, if the drawing specifies 1.5 mm brass while the BOM states 1.2 mm, or the sample uses Brand A Driver while the purchasing BOM only states “Dimmable Driver,” inspectors cannot determine which version to follow.

2) Establish the Golden Sample and Finish Sample

The Golden Sample will help verify the overall form, assembly and final look, while the Finish Sample will help to control color, texture, and gloss. In cases of Antique Brass and other finishes like Brushed Bronze, hand rubbed finishes and handmade glass, don’t use description like “Gold” or “Bronze”. Each approved sample should be numbered and connected to the appropriate Revision.

3) Define Dimensions, Tolerances, Color Variation, and Appearance Standards

Classify dimensions by function. Critical Dimensions include mounting holes, the Canopy, glass interfaces, module connection holes, and other dimensions that directly affect installation and assembly. General Dimensions cover overall dimensions that do not affect assembly. Appearance Standards cover visual requirements such as scratches, weld marks, color variation, bubbles, and texture.

4) Establish Inspection Items, Sampling Rules, and Defect Criteria

The inspection plan should be a specification of the items to be inspected, when they are to be inspected, the number of units to sample and what constitutes a rejection. Attribute sampling methods like ANSI/ASQ Z1.4 can be used to specify the sample size, acceptance/rejection criteria for volume production, when the lot size is known, the inspection level, and the AQL. Discuss Critical, Major and Minor Defects before so that the buyer doesn’t think something is major and the supplier thinks it is minor and cosmetic.

Decorative Lighting Factory Quality Inspection

Decorative Lighting Factory Quality Inspection

2. How Should Incoming Materials and Purchased Components Be Inspected (IQC)?

After the raw materials and purchased materials have entered the production process, the main function of IQC is to verify whether the actual materials received are consistent with the BOM, drawing and approved sample.

1) Inspect Metal Material, Thickness, and Surface Condition

Check material certificates of brass, zinc alloy, steel and other base materials. Check tube and sheet thickness, raw parts for porosity, cracks, oxidation and rust spots. When semi-finished parts are coated or plated, but not the original, use sample coating thickness as per project requirements. The thickness of the coating should be in accordance with the specific base material, finish process, corrosion resistance requirements and the project standard.

Inspection of Fixture Component Dimensions and Material Thickness

Inspection of Fixture Component Dimensions and Material Thickness

2) Inspect Dimensions, Color, and Defects of Glass, Crystal, and Stone

Check large decorative parts individually when applicable for bubbles, chipped edges, cracks, discoloration, dimensions and mounting interfaces. See if they are the same color and if they are the same light transmission for crystal and glass from the same batch. Compare colour range and texture of stone to the approved sample. Specify tolerances independently on the drawing for critical dimensions that are important for assembly or installation; these tolerances should be in accordance with the size of the parts, the processing method and requirements for fit.

3) Verify Incoming Electrical Components Such as LEDs, Drivers, Lamp Holders, and Wires

Confirm light source and Driver brand and model are correct for BOM; confirm CCT, CRI, power, input/output parameters and certification information. Where the project allows for acceptable ranges for CCT, luminous flux or any other parameter, then IQC shall check the parameter against the applicable Specification. Also check that all important parts, like wires, Drivers and lamp holders, comply with the UL or CE certification configuration.

4) Inspect and Manage Batches of Fasteners, Suspension Parts, and Other Critical Purchased Components

When it comes to load-bearing screws, suspension chains, steel cables and other components, pay attention to specification, surface and structural changes. Separate suspension components that support the entire fixture load from the normal decorative suspension screws. Keep supplier, batch and inspection records as required for tracking structural problems. The batch records of purchased parts can reference the manufacturer’s record, the date the part was received, and the inspection record, and can also help regulate material and finish differences between batches within a project.

3. How Do You Control Quality During Component Processing (IPQC)?

After incoming inspection confirms that materials and purchased components meet requirements, control dimensions, structural features, and assembly datums during processing to prevent defects from reaching the finish and final assembly stages.

1) Castings: Check Porosity, Shrinkage Cavities, Sand Holes, and Deformation

Porosity, shrinkage cavities, sand holes, deformation and dimensional deviation are some of the common casting defects. Decorative items that need polishing and plating can have small holes that are more noticeable after such finishing work; be sure to screen out such holes before you do the finishing.

2) Sheet Metal, CNC, and Bent-Tube Parts: Control Assembly Datums

Checks such as dimensions, hole spacing, angles, concentricity, bend radius and locating holes are important. All of the dimensions which directly influence assembly should be considered Critical Dimensions. For instance, a small deviation from the true angle at each of the connection holes on an eight arm chandelier might not be noticeable per part, but the errors after assembly can make the whole fixture noticeably asymmetric.

3) Welded Structures: Check Both Weld Quality and Overall Deformation

After welding, check for overall deformation, angles, symmetry, in addition to incomplete welds, missed welds, weld buildup and burn-through. The large ring fixtures tend to get distorted. Check overall roundness and structural dimensions after welding, prior to grinding & finishing operations. This minimizes rework on the surfaces, reshaping or repair welding after the finish has been done.

Component Processing and Welding Quality

Component Processing and Welding Quality

4) Glass, Stone, and Crystal Processing

Pay attention to cut dimensions, hole position, edge treatment and mounting interfaces. When glass hole positions vary after the related metal mounting parts have been processed, it is possible that there may be a problem of the glass and metal parts not being able to assemble.

5) Confirm Critical Dimensions Before Finish

Do the steps Metalwork Complete, Trial Assembly, Critical Dimension Check, Finish. Verify positions of holes, hole structure and assembly before plating, PVD, painting or other finish operations. It can be reworked after finish (drilling, welding, reworking) which will increase rework and may cause damage to the finish surface.

4. How Do You Control the Quality of Surface Finishes and Decorative Effects?

Once the components have been processed and critical dimensions are verified, monitor surface finish and final appearance. This stage not only impacts on appearance but also consistency from batch to batch.

1) What Should Be Checked for Plating, PVD, Coating, and Painting?

Defects are color variation, scratches, pitting, pinholes, runs, exposed substrate, blistering, peeling and uneven plating. When inspecting, gather like parts of like fixtures together for comparison.

Surface Quality Inspection After Coating

Surface Quality Inspection After Coating

2) Use the Finish Sample to Control Color, Texture, and Gloss

The same Base Material + Surface Preparation + Finish Process will be applied to the Finish Sample as will be used in mass production. For instance a Brass finish applied to a brass sample may not be the same final colour and texture as a Brass finish applied to a steel sample, as various substrates and various pretreatments may result in different final colours and textures.

Comparison of Different Finish Samples

Comparison of Different Finish Samples

3) How Should Appearance Defects Be Evaluated?

The appearance standards should contain the following information: viewing distance + light situation + visible-surface grade + defect type. Appearance grades for the primary front-facing visual area and for the backplate may be different, when it is completely hidden after installation.

4) How Should Acceptable Variation in Hand-Applied Finishes Be Defined?

Antique, Patina and Hand-brushed finishes naturally cause some variation as it is a process. At time of acceptance, check the colour, light/dark range, texture and total range of vision of the accepted sample. The pieces need not be exactly alike, as in a machine-printed surface.

5) How Do You Control Consistency Between Production Batches?

Hotel projects may be produced in several batches. Retain the Master Finish Sample + Finish Formula/Process Record + Batch Sample. Compare each subsequent batch with the Master Sample before approving the production Finish.

5. What Should Be Inspected During Complete Fixture Assembly?

Complete fixture assembly brings together dimensional and process deviations from earlier component stages. The emphasis should be on overall geometry, connection structures, decorative features and electrical assembly.

1) Check Overall Dimensions, Arm Angles, Level, and Symmetry

Re-check the over-all fixture diameter, height and suspension rod after assembly. With multi arm fixtures, inspect arm angles, leveling and symmetry. If the arms are slightly off center in one arm it might not be noticed individually but when there are multiple arms, it can cause a significant overall tilt or asymmetry.

2) Check Suspension Rods, Steel Cables, Screws, and Structural Connectors

Verify correct installation of fasteners, specifications of load bearing components are correct, steel-cable tension, orientation of suspension rods, concealed connectors are correct. Parts that are not installed, or are installed incorrectly or not tightened, can loosen further during vibration during transport or long-term suspension.

3) Check Installation of Glass, Crystal, and Decorative Components

Inspect glass and crystal for quantity, location, spacing and securing, chipped edges, stains, scratches and looseness. Use numbered drawings to control the positions of repeated decorative parts for large quantities.

4) Check Wire Routing, Connections, and Internal Electrical Assembly

Install an internal wiring that avoids pinching and insulation problems. Ensure terminals are tight, correct in polarity and properly grounded; ensure wires are not near sharp edges or high-temperature surfaces. Check the condition of fixing of Drivers, terminals and other electrical parts.

5) Factory Pre-Assembly and Installation Fit Check for Large Chandeliers

Pre-assemble the entire fixture or key modules in the factory for large custom chandeliers to verify the overall shape, the interfaces of the modules, the mounting holes and the installation sequence on site. Meanwhile, verify that the Module Connection, Wiring Interface and the glass installation locations agree. This can be used to determine where individual modules satisfy dimensions requirements but are unable to connect to each other or where site wiring or installation sequence may prove impractical.

6. What Functional and Safety Tests Are Required for Decorative Lighting?

Functional and safety testing primarily focus on the operation of the electrical controls, compatibility of the dimming, insulation and grounding and the safety of large fixtures. Keep essential test notes as per Goals of the target market and requirements of the project.

1) Electrical Function Tests

Power-on test: Check finished products based on project quality plan. Turn on each fixture, and inspect for operating status, apparent color changes, extreme brightness, burnt out LEDs, and visible flicker. Check CCT and CRI values of optics as specified by the project (sampling or dedicated test equipment).
Dimming compatibility test: Test using the dimmer actually specified for the project such as Triac, 0-10V, DALI and more. Monitor for flicker, instability or abnormal start up during dimming. System compatibility testing should not be replaced by confirming the Driver model alone since the actual fixture load and the control equipment should also be included.
Input voltage test: Run the input voltage as per the relevant input voltage for the project market (120V in North America, 230V in Europe) and the Driver and the whole fixture work normally.

2) Safety Performance Tests

Insulation resistance and Dielectric withstand test (Hi-pot): Set up test conditions according to product certification and applicable specifications. For instance, UL and CE/LVD projects in North America and Europe must carry out their individual requirements to assure that the product insulation system is capable of withstanding the specified dielectric withstand and insulation requirements.
Ground continuity test: Ensure that a reliable ground path between the enclosure, Canopy and other associated metal structures is established for protective grounding fixtures as per applicable certification requirements. With custom chandeliers, look for missing or loose Canopy grounding screws and poor electrical contact.
Mechanical load/suspension test: If the chandelier is heavier, the static load test conditions are determined according to the project requirements, product structure and standards in use. Inspect suspension chains, suspension rods, Canopy, suspension points and connection structures for deformation, cracking or becoming loosen.

Fixture Electrical Function and Safety Testing

Fixture Electrical Function and Safety Testing

3) Environmental Reliability Tests

The environmental reliability tests can be sampled based on the project environment and product requirements.
Salt spray test: If the project is in coastal zones, high humidity or higher corrosion resistance requirements, the neutral salt spray test time can be defined based on the project requirements, and the oxidation, blistering, coating falling off and other defects can be checked.
Continuous lighting aging test: Conduct continuous lighting aging test by project quality requirements and see if there are dead LEDs on the LED, if the Driver fails, or if the LED, Driver or entire fixture shows abnormal discoloration.
Vibration simulation test: As applicable to the transportation method, add vibration simulation test for high-value or large chandeliers to see if shipping vibration can cause wiring to loosen, hardware connections to loosen or other components to become loose.

4) Verify Documents and Certificates

Check models, key electrical parts and actual product configuration before shipping to ensure shipped product is within the scope of the certificate. Certification documents of other models should not be replaced by the current product because it could create problems in customs clearance and project acceptance.

7. How Should Final Inspection and Pre-Shipment Quality Control Be Performed?

At the PSI stage, mainly verify that finished products match the approved samples, final drawings, BOM, and order requirements, while also checking packaging and documentation.

1) Final Comparison of Finished Products Against the Golden Sample, Drawings, and Specifications

Check on each model: dimensions, form, Finish, assembly and optical effect; compare with the Golden Sample, Finish Sample and final Revision. If deviations are present, rework/remanufacture/Deviation Approval should be determined based on Defect Classification.

2) Verify Dimensions, Quantity, Accessories, Labels, and Installation Hardware

e-check the quantity, model and Fixture ID, and make sure the mounting screws, clips, instructions and spare parts are all there. Labels, certification numbers and parameters must line up with the product itself and its paperwork — get this wrong and you’ll be chasing discrepancies long after shipment.

3) How Is AQL Sampling Inspection Applied to Decorative Lighting?

Standard AQL 1.0 sampling can be employed for standardized stock fixtures, based on lot size and quality specifications. Calculate actual sample size and Ac/Re criteria using Lot Size, Inspection Level and sampling standard. For smaller numbers of large custom chandeliers, critical structures, suspension connections and electrical safety items, DO NOT use AQL sampling as the only method of inspection–inspect them by project requirements.

4) How Are Critical, Major, and Minor Defects Classified?

Critical Defects are safety or compliance issues such as potential electric shock, load-bearing structural flaws and mis-configured certification. Major Defects consist of Functional Failure, Finish Errors visible to the naked eye, Critical Dimensions Out of Tolerance, and Prevents Installation. Minor Defects are appearance defect with small effect to function, but overall appearance is still acceptable. In the inspection plan, establish ahead of time acceptance, rework and release requirements for each defect level.

5) Check Packaging and Transportation Protection

Use separate cushioning protection on crystal and glass elements and to incorporate scratch protection into completed hardware. Apart and number large fixtures based on the structure. For modular large chandeliers, create a Fixture ID → Module ID → Crate ID association to facilitate site receiving teams to identify which fixture, module, and drawing each crate belongs to. If exported products are packed in wooden crates, check the internal fixing, cushioning, and construction of the crates.

6) Which Quality Issues Must Be Resolved Before Shipment Approval?

Electrical safety, structural load bearing, incorrect product configuration, unacceptable Finish deviation, dimensions that prevent installation, absence of accessories and/or unacceptable packaging structure must be corrected and re-inspected prior to release. Appearance deviations may be addressed by a mutual Deviation Approval for the minor deviations.

8. What Are the Most Common Decorative Lighting Quality Defects and Their Causes?

Common defects can help trace the production stage where a problem originated. The following summarizes them by appearance, structure, electrical performance, and batch consistency.

1) Appearance and Finish Defects

a. Blisters, darkening or fast oxidation of the plate during the plating operation.
They can be caused by several reasons, such as insufficient metal preparation, coating thickness or quality, metal not being in the proper state for coating, or the coating finish protection level not being appropriate for the project. Establish corrosion resistance and salt spray requirement during the project and inspect them by batch in case of corrosive environment such as coastal area.
b. Batch-to-batch color variation
Color difference can occur if plating/coating is done in separate batches that use different pretreatment and/or processing parameters. For volume projects like hotels, create the same finish batch, if possible, and keep a Master Finish Sample or batch sample for comparison.

c. Surface scratches and impact marks
These issues may occur during assembly, internal factory handling, or transportation. Protect finished hardware surfaces after Finish, and provide separate protection and packaging for fragile glass and crystal components.

Appearance and Finish Defects

Appearance and Finish Defects

2) Mechanical and Structural Defects

a. Suspension point, chain weld, and connection problems
Suspension point welds, cracks, or poorly connected sections have a direct impact on installation safety. When welding, use IPQC to check the critical weld and do the necessary structural verification of the load-bearing structure according to the product structure and the project requirement.
b. Dimensional deviation and inconsistent suspension-rod lengths
Common causes include failure to confirm first-piece dimensions, inconsistent machining datums, or changes in production tolerances. Use FAI to confirm first-piece dimensions, continue sampling during production, and recheck consistency between products before shipment.
c. Chipped or broken crystal and glass
Such defects can be caused by the incoming material, processing, assembly or transportation. Eliminate visible defects during IQC; manage the installation process during assembly; and provide additional cushioning protection during shipping.

3) Electrical Safety and Functional Defects

a. Dead LEDs, flicker, and early Driver failure
Check the LEDs and Driver, heat-dissipation structure, and wiring quality. Lock the critical electrical components in the BOM before mass production, then perform power-on and applicable aging checks at the finished-product stage.
b. Abnormal dimming or flicker
When the Driver and dimmer are incompatible, the system installed may flicker, fail to dim down all the way, or start up abnormally. When sampling, test using the dimming equipment actually to be used in the project, and perform mass production inspection using the same configuration.
c. Missing grounding and insulation problems
If the electrical structure is not updated after a custom design change, or grounding components are omitted during assembly, safety and certification issues may result. Perform Hi-pot, ground continuity, and other required checks according to project requirements, and verify the certification documents against the actual product configuration.

4) Batch Consistency Issues

Typical cases are when the approved sample is okay but mass-produced fixtures vary from it based on material, finish or electrical configuration. The common reasons are that the Golden Sample and BOM are not completely locked, material or subcontracted process changes during mass production, and changes that have not been formally documented.

9. Conclusion

Quality control for decorative lighting should be related to the drawings, BOM (Bill of Materials), approved samples, production process and final acceptance. When building custom projects, make sure to examine not only the look, but the construction, electrical needs, and site conditions as well. Specify the Final Drawing, Golden Sample, Finish Sample, BOM and inspection standards at the front end, and apply the IQC, IPQC and assembly inspection to minimize issues during production.

From development, sample approval, material and Finish control to production inspection, functional testing and pre-shipment quality management, Postmodern Lighting will be able to support hotels, commercial spaces and custom lighting projects. Specific inspection items and acceptance criteria could be set based on the product structure, target market and project Specification. Get in touch for a decorative lighting quality-control and custom production solution for your project.